| Platinum | Tacos El Guero |
| Gold | Monterrey Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Chilangos Mexican Pizzas |
| Bronze | La Juanita |
| Top Pick | Blue Tequila |
| Top Pick | El Ranchito |
| Top Pick | El Tapatio Restaurant |
| Top Pick | La Monja Blanca |
| Top Pick | Navarretes |
| Top Pick | Rudy Navarrete's Mexican Food |