| Platinum | Buffalo Alice |
| Gold | El Fredo Pizza |
| Silver | P's Pizza House |
| Bronze | Jerry's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bob Roe's Point After |
| Top Pick | Chilangos Mexican Pizzas |
| Top Pick | Godfather's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Point After Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rosies Pizza - South Sioux City |
| Top Pick | Tony's Pizza |