| Platinum | Jimmy John's |
| Gold | Pickerman's Soup & Sandwich |
| Silver | Chilangos Mexican Pizzas |
| Bronze | Oto Pub & Grub |
| Top Pick | Firehouse Subs |
| Top Pick | Livengoodies |
| Top Pick | Livengoodies Bakery |
| Top Pick | Pierce Street Coffee Works |
| Top Pick | Point After Pizza |
| Top Pick | Westside Pizza |