| Platinum | Junk & Disorderly Flea Market |
| Gold | Heart & Soul Treasures Flea Market |
| Silver | Goodwill of the Great Plains |
| Bronze | Sweet Repeats Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | 4less Sales |
| Top Pick | Bargain Hunters Thrift & More |
| Top Pick | Envy My Closet |
| Top Pick | Junior League Discovery Shop |
| Top Pick | Love It Moore Consignments |
| Top Pick | Visions of Home |